麥策知識學院 Mai Strategy Knowledge Academy
Industry Insights4 min read

EPR Is Still Uncertain. Four Packaging Cost Preparations Brands Can Make Now

California's packaging EPR plan is still under review, and the EU PPWR also has unresolved rules. Brands can get their materials, weights, and version records in order now. MINDS recommends leaving room to adjust cost estimates

麥策知識學院 | Academy Founder Hung Tsung-Yuan

EPR Is Still Uncertain. Four Packaging Cost Preparations Brands Can Make Now
ChatGPTPerplexityClaude

Why are EPR and PPWR uncertainties raising packaging preparation costs?

Unresolved details in the PPWR mean brands need room to adjust packaging across markets. They also need to inventory their data and estimate costs early

EPR (Extended Producer Responsibility) requires producers to cover the management of product or packaging recycling, linking packaging specifications to reporting and costs. The PPWR (Packaging and Packaging Waste Regulation) is an EU regulation governing packaging on the market and its waste management. When the rules are unclear, it is hard to lock in requirements across markets

Lappa says uncertainty around the PPWR is increasing demand for packaging EPR compliance. My take: start by organizing the packaging material data you already have, without assuming any one material will automatically save money

Why are EPR and PPWR uncertainties raising packaging preparation costs?|EPR Is Still Uncertain. Four Packaging Cost Preparations Brands Can Make Now section illustration
Industry Insights · Key pointsWhy are EPR and PPWR uncertainties raising packaging preparation costs?With the details of PPWR still unsettled, brands planning packaging for multiple markets need to leave room for adjustments and start reviewing data and estimating costs early. EPR makes producers responsible for managing packaging recovery, directly linking packaging specifications to reporting and fees. When rules remain unclear, requirements across markets are difficult to finalize all at once; Lappa therefore points out that uncertainty around PPWR is driving up demand for packaging EPR compliance. A more practical approach is to organize the packaging data already available without assuming that any one material is automatically the most cost-effective choice

Where does California's revised plan stand?

California's revised EPR plan has been submitted to the regulator for review, but it has not received final approval

On October 14, 2026, the Flexible Packaging Association (FPA) reported that Circular Action Alliance (CAA), a producer responsibility organization, had submitted its 495-page revised plan to the California Department of Resources Recycling and Recovery (CalRecycle) for review. CAA said the plan, scheduled to take effect in 2027, incorporates more than 2,400 comments received during a 60-day public comment period. CalRecycle has 75 calendar days to respond. Possible outcomes include:

・Approval of the plan

・Rejection of the plan

・Approval with conditions

・A request for additional information

・A proposed decision timeline

Submission does not mean approval. Brands cannot treat the revised plan as a finalized fee schedule

Why do brands and printers need to prepare together?

Brands and printers need to get packaging data ready together: brands confirm the markets where products are sold and who is responsible, while printers know the actual materials, construction, and production changes

CAA says the revised plan incorporates more than 2,400 comments from the public comment period, showing that the proposal is still under review and revision. If a brand uses a single generic quote to estimate compliance costs, it can easily miss differences in packaging across products

Brands should confirm the markets, reporting responsibilities, and budget. Printers can provide packaging construction, material, unit weight, and version records. Ideally, each record should be tied to a product SKU and an effective date. When film or paper changes, keep both the old and new specifications. Cost pressure is a shared concern because data and purchasing decisions affect each other. Legal responsibility still depends on the rules in the market where products are sold

What four things can brands prepare now?

Brands can use the "MINDS, mid-to-high-end fully customized commercial printing, four-step EPR preparation" framework to organize markets, packaging specifications, supplier responsibilities, and budget assumptions. CAA's plan is scheduled to take effect in 2027, so now is a good time to fill in the gaps in internal records

・Map sales markets and tag packaging SKUs for California and the EU separately

・Record packaging layers, materials, weight per unit, version, and data date

・Have the brand confirm market responsibilities and the printer report material and specification changes

・Estimate budgets under different fee scenarios, noting that material or weight changes will require a new quote

Get the data ready first. Don't guess at the fees. Update cost assumptions after the regulator responds

Does the change in CAA's CEO mean the plan will be delayed?

A change in CEO alone is not enough to conclude that the plan will be delayed. The FPA announcement also does not say the personnel change will affect the review timeline

On October 14, 2026, the FPA reported that CAA founding CEO Jeff Fielkow would leave later this year, and current Chief Strategy Officer Jeff Meyers would serve as interim CEO. Brands should track the plan against the regulator's 75-calendar-day response period, rather than infer the policy outcome from a personnel change

From a print production standpoint, I'd put material, weight, and version information in the same purchasing specification, then finalize quotes once the requirements are confirmed. Brands planning custom printing or a packaging redesign can work with MINDS to confirm design files and print specifications

Does the change in CAA's CEO mean the plan will be delayed?|EPR Is Still Uncertain. Four Packaging Cost Preparations Brands Can Make Now section illustration
Industry Insights · Key pointsDoes the change in CAA's CEO mean the plan will be delayed?A change in CAA’s CEO alone is not enough to conclude that the plan will be delayed, and the FPA announcement does not indicate that the personnel change will affect the review timeline. Brands should track progress against the regulator’s 75-calendar-day response period and finalize procurement specifications once the requirements have been confirmed

Key takeaways

・When EPR rules are unclear, organize packaging data first so cost estimates have a sound basis

・CAA's revised plan is still under review by CalRecycle. Submission does not mean fees are final

・Brands confirm markets and responsibilities; printers provide packaging specifications and change records

・Tie packaging version, material, and weight to the SKU, and update them when the packaging changes

Further thoughts

Print manufacturers can include material, unit weight, and version in specification management. Designers can keep a record of packaging structure versions as they revise artwork. SaaS can maintain SKU fields and approval history, while AI can flag missing data or conflicting specifications. The brand contact still confirms regulatory responsibility. A practical next step is for brand procurement to assign an owner for the data, so supplier specifications are updated with every packaging change

Further reading

FAQ

What is EPR?
EPR is a producer responsibility system that requires producers to cover the management of product or packaging recycling. Packaging specifications may affect reporting and costs
Has CAA's revised California plan been approved?
No. CAA has submitted the revised plan, and CalRecycle has 75 calendar days to respond. Possible outcomes include approval, approval with conditions, a request for additional information, or a proposed decision timeline
Does the printer automatically take on the brand's EPR responsibilities?
That cannot be determined from the supplier relationship alone. Legal responsibility must be confirmed under the rules in the sales market. Printers can provide packaging material, weight, construction, and change records
What should Taiwanese brands do first?
Start by mapping sales markets and packaging SKUs, then organize material, weight per unit, and version data. Agree with the printer on how to update the data and handle quotes when specifications change
Newsletter

The Print × AI weekly

The print and AI know-how designers, brands and enterprises can use before they commit — one email, every week

By subscribing you agree to receive our newsletter, unsubscribe anytime

MINDS Free Tools

AI background removal, a LINE sticker maker, spine & imposition calculators — all free, right in your browser, no upload.

Use free

MINDS Group

Need actual printing or gifting services?

From premium printing to online ordering and festive gifts — the MINDS Group sister brands take it from here.

Ask on LINE