麥策知識學院 Mai Strategy Knowledge Academy
Printing Knowledge4 min read

Testing PSD Templates in ArtCraft: 4 Checks Before Launch

ArtCraft is being tested with real files and Photoshop templates, but opening a file and handing it off are two different tests. MINDS lays out four practical checks so teams trying a free tool for the first time know what to verify and when to hold off on adopting it

麥策知識學院 | Academy Founder Hung Tsung-Yuan

Testing PSD Templates in ArtCraft: 4 Checks Before Launch
ChatGPTPerplexityClaude

What can an ArtCraft test actually prove?

ArtCraft was included in a comparison of free alternatives to Adobe Photoshop, Adobe's image-editing software, using real files. A separate short video checks whether it can open Photoshop templates. ArtCraft real-file and Photoshop-template test What we can confirm so far is what the tests covered. There aren't enough item-by-item results to judge template fidelity or print readiness. I wouldn't take "tested with templates" to mean "proven ready for production."

Being able to open a PSD, Photoshop's native file format, which preserves layers, text, and some effect information for further editing, only clears the first hurdle. Editing, saving, and handing off the file still need to be checked. A similar-looking screen doesn't mean the next person can work with the file structure without trouble. This is where the design and print teams can easily come away with different expectations

What can an ArtCraft test actually prove?|Testing PSD Templates in ArtCraft: 4 Checks Before Launch section illustration
Printing Knowledge · Key pointsWhat can an ArtCraft test actually prove?ArtCraft was included in a comparison of free Photoshop alternatives and tested with real files. A short video also checks whether it can open Photoshop templates, but there are not enough item-by-item results to determine template fidelity or whether the output is suitable. The key point is that opening a PSD only clears the first hurdle; subsequent editing, saving, and handoff determine whether it can go into production. For example, the image may look similar even though the file’s layer and text structure has changed, making it difficult for the next designer or print professional to continue the work

Why isn't opening a PSD enough?

Opening a PSD doesn't guarantee that its layers, text, fonts, and output meet the original requirements. MINDS, a mid-to-high-end fully custom commercial printer, recommends breaking acceptance down into four checks and comparing each one against the original file

・Layers: Toggle visibility, move elements, or adjust effects to confirm they can still be edited separately

・Text: Change a line of text, then check for shifts in line breaks, letter spacing, and layout

・Fonts: Make sure no fonts are missing or substituted. Pay special attention to tightly packed content such as packaging labels

・Output: Check the output file's dimensions, color, and other required settings against the print shop's requirements for the job

Even a slight squeeze in the text of a print file can make a label harder to read. Merged layers or changed effects can also make later revisions a hassle. These four checks don't assume ArtCraft will fail. They show the team what to look at

How do you test it with a real template?

Use a copy of a PSD the team already works with. Make an edit in ArtCraft, save and export the file, then check it through the usual handoff process. That's how you find out whether it can fit into production

・1. Choose a template with multiple layers, text, and a real layout. Don't test with a single image alone

・2. Edit a line of text and one layer, save as a new file, reopen it, and compare each item with the original

・3. Export the file using the current print submission process, then ask the prepress lead to confirm it meets the requirements for the job

Keep the original file

Testing the kind of content you actually edit tells you more than simply opening a file. MINDS recommends noting any issues alongside the file, such as text that shifted, an effect that changed, or something that needs fixing after export. When the team tries a different template or tool, they'll know which checks to repeat

What work is a free tool suited for at first?

ArtCraft can first be tried on small, reversible edits. Whether it should take on formal work still depends on the results of all four checks

・Advantages: The team can compare candidate tools using existing templates without changing the whole workflow at the outset

・Advantages: Designers can first check whether their usual edits feel straightforward and whether files can be handed off

・Drawbacks: The video information available so far doesn't include item-by-item test results, so it can't guarantee that every template will be compatible

・Drawbacks: If fonts, layers, or output differ, the time spent fixing them may cancel out the savings on tool costs

My take is to start with test files. Don't rush to hand it the only copy of a production file. When the team records the results, it can tell whether an issue comes from the template, the software, or the handoff process

How should the print shop and brand client review the files together?

The print shop and brand client should first agree on what each side needs to check, then use the same test file to see whether ArtCraft fits the handoff process

・The design team keeps the original PSD and saves a separate ArtCraft test file, so the working file doesn't get overwritten during testing

・The print team spells out the file and output requirements for the job. "It opens" doesn't replace a prepress check

・The brand client checks the text and layout version to make sure the file submitted for printing is the approved design

If a brand client is about to send design files to a print shop, they can ask about submission requirements and include both the original file and the test file. For fully custom commercial printing, they can also contact MINDS to confirm how the files will fit into the production process before deciding whether to switch tools

How should the print shop and brand client review the files together?|Testing PSD Templates in ArtCraft: 4 Checks Before Launch section illustration
Printing Knowledge · Key pointsHow should the print shop and brand client review the files together?The print shop, design team, and brand client should first clarify their acceptance criteria, then use the same ArtCraft test file to confirm that the handoff process works for everyone. For example, the design team can keep the original PSD and save a separate test file, while the brand client checks that the print-ready file matches the approved proof. For fully customized commercial printing, bring the original and test files to MINDS to ask about handoff and production requirements before deciding whether to switch tools

Key takeaways

・Opening a PSD only proves that the file can be read

・The layers, text, fonts, and output all need to pass before it's ready for production

・Test a copy of a real template first. Don't risk the only working file

・The print shop should spell out its submission requirements, and the brand client should check the final layout

A broader takeaway

Designers can test edits with a real template, print shops can spell out their submission requirements, and brand clients can keep an eye on content versions. AI tool and SaaS teams can use the same approach: test edits and output with files from real work, not just a polished demo

Further reading

FAQ

Can ArtCraft replace Photoshop outright?
The information available so far confirms that ArtCraft has been tested with real files and Photoshop templates, but there aren't enough item-by-item results to show that it can fully replace Photoshop
If a PSD opens, is it ready to send to print?
Not necessarily. You still need to check that the layers, text, fonts, and output meet the submission requirements for the job
How do you test a free Photoshop alternative?
Use a copy of a PSD the team already works with to test editing, saving, and exporting. Then follow the usual process to confirm the print team can take it from there
Should I keep the original file when trying ArtCraft?
Yes. Save the original PSD separately and save the test file as a new version. That way, you can compare them item by item and return to the original if needed
Newsletter

The Print × AI weekly

The print and AI know-how designers, brands and enterprises can use before they commit — one email, every week

By subscribing you agree to receive our newsletter, unsubscribe anytime

MINDS Free Tools

Imposition calculator and preflight file check — free prepress tools, right in your browser.

Use free

MINDS Group

Need actual printing or gifting services?

From premium printing to online ordering and festive gifts — the MINDS Group sister brands take it from here.

Ask on LINE