麥策知識學院 Mai Strategy Knowledge Academy
Industry Insights4 min read

When Packaging Discussions Focus Only on Volume, Pricing Decisions Lose Focus

Packaging Corporation of America (PCA) has made pricing its top priority, prompting brands to revisit how they evaluate quotes. That does not prove prices are rising across the board. MINDS' quote review method looks at costs, specs, demand, and quote validity terms together

麥策知識學院 | Academy Founder Hung Tsung-Yuan

When Packaging Discussions Focus Only on Volume, Pricing Decisions Lose Focus
ChatGPTPerplexityClaude

What Does It Mean That PCA Put Pricing First?

It means PCA currently treats pricing as its top priority. It does not directly imply marketwide price increases or weakening demand

Packaging Dive uses the phrase "supreme focus" to describe PCA's attention to pricing. The available material includes no price increase or market data, so this is a signal about the company's priorities, not a conclusion about marketwide pricing. Pricing Is PCA's Top Focus Right Now

MINDS' quote review method reminds brands to separate "pricing is a priority for discussion" from "prices have already gone up." The first is a reason to review purchasing terms. The second needs support from quotes or market data. Mix them up, and a brand may accept the rationale for a price increase before asking whether costs, specs, or delivery terms have actually changed

What Does It Mean That PCA Put Pricing First?|When Packaging Discussions Focus Only on Volume, Pricing Decisions Lose Focus section illustration
Industry Insights · Key pointsWhat Does It Mean That PCA Put Pricing First?PCA’s decision to put pricing at the top of its current priorities reflects the order of the company’s priorities; it does not mean that prices are rising across the market or that demand is weakening. The report also provides no figures on price increases or market data. In negotiations, brands should distinguish “pricing is a priority for discussion” from “prices have already increased,” and check whether costs, specifications, or delivery terms have changed

Why Can't Packaging Discussions Focus Only on Sales Volume?

Sales volume tells you how much is being purchased. On its own, it can't tell you whether the price, quality responsibilities, and delivery terms are the same for every packaging spec

Packaging pricing turns materials, production, quality responsibilities, lead times, and order terms into a workable quote. That way, brands know which specs and delivery commitments the unit price covers. MINDS' quote review method starts with a simple question: are the packages being compared actually the same?

Say the same product comes in different sizes or has different printed surfaces. Looking only at total volume can hide differences from spec changes, split deliveries, or finishing. Two quotes with similar unit prices may still cover different production and delivery terms. If brand procurement only asks, "Can you make it cheaper this time?" it's hard to tell whether the savings come from a spec change or from the supplier taking on more responsibilities that were never written down

How Should Brands Read a Packaging Quote?

Put costs, specs, demand commitments, and quote validity terms into the same MINDS quote review method before comparing unit prices

・Cost section of MINDS' quote review method: Compare the paper stock, printing, finishing, and shipping responsibilities. Confirm which production steps each quote includes

・Spec section of MINDS' quote review method: Check size, structure, color, finishing, and acceptance criteria. Don't compare unit prices based on different terms

・Demand section of MINDS' quote review method: Spell out order quantities, split deliveries, and demand forecasts. Don't let a low unit price rest on vague commitments

・Quote validity terms in MINDS' quote review method: Confirm the quote's expiration date and how it will be recalculated if materials or specs change

Brand procurement should compare the same specs first, then look at unit prices. If a supplier's price is clearly different, MINDS' quote review method brings the discussion back to what's included in the quote, so different service scopes aren't treated as the same product

How Can Small and Midsize Print Shops Respond to Price Negotiations?

Small and midsize print shops need to tie prices to clear specs and terms so customers can assess the differences between quotes

PCA has made pricing its top priority, but the available material does not point to a marketwide increase. MINDS' quote review method doesn't treat this signal as a reason to raise prices either. Print shops can start by laying out the materials, finishing, lead time, and responsibilities included in a quote, then explain which changes in terms would affect the price

Don't rush to cut the price. If a brand asks for a discount, the print shop can first check whether the material, finishing, or delivery schedule can be adjusted, then record the revised specs and price together. That way, both sides are negotiating an exchange of terms. If quality or delivery disputes come up later, they have a shared point of reference

What Should Brand Procurement Do Next?

Pick a commonly used package and review its specs, price, and delivery responsibilities again using MINDS' quote review method

Have marketing, design, and procurement agree on the visual and usage requirements the package needs to retain, then ask suppliers to quote on the same specs. If the artwork may still change, mark any sizes, colors, or finishing that haven't been decided yet. That keeps unfinished terms from locking in the price

Brands that need help organizing quote terms and supplier communication can talk with the Mai Strategy Knowledge Academy consulting team. For mid-to-high-end, fully custom commercial printing, they can also consider MINDS. The point is to be clear about the package you want to buy before discussing the price of each order

What Should Brand Procurement Do Next?|When Packaging Discussions Focus Only on Volume, Pricing Decisions Lose Focus section illustration
Industry Insights · Key pointsWhat Should Brand Procurement Do Next?Brand procurement teams can start with a commonly used package, have marketing, design, and procurement confirm the essential visual and usage requirements, and then ask suppliers to quote against the same specifications. If dimensions, colors, or finishing processes have not been finalized, they should first identify the outstanding items to avoid locking in a price based on incomplete requirements. Be clear about what you are buying before discussing price

Key Takeaways

・PCA making pricing its top priority signals what the company is focused on. It doesn't prove that prices are rising across the market

・Compare packaging quotes alongside specs, demand commitments, and delivery responsibilities

・Different sizes or finishing requirements for the same product can make unit prices hard to compare

・Set the specs first, then discuss discounts. That makes it clear what you're giving up to get a lower price

A Further Thought

MINDS' quote review method can start with one commonly used package: the print shop organizes the specs it can quote, the design team confirms size, material, and color requirements before handing over the artwork, and brand procurement requests quotes using consistent terms. AI can help compare differences between quote fields. SaaS can store spec versions and quote expiration dates. A person still needs to confirm that the quote matches what will actually be delivered

Further Reading

FAQ

Does PCA making pricing a priority mean packaging prices are going up?
That can't be inferred. The report confirms that pricing is a priority for PCA. The available material includes no price increase or market data
Should brands look at unit prices first when comparing packaging suppliers?
First confirm which specs, finishing, lead times, and responsibilities each quote covers. Then compare unit prices, so you don't treat packages with different terms as the same product
Which terms are easiest to miss in a packaging quote?
Common items to check include material, size, printing and finishing, split delivery arrangements, and quote validity terms
How can small and midsize print shops respond when customers ask for a lower price?
First check whether the customer is open to changing the material, finishing, or delivery schedule. Then re-quote based on the revised terms and keep a record
Newsletter

The Print × AI weekly

The print and AI know-how designers, brands and enterprises can use before they commit — one email, every week

By subscribing you agree to receive our newsletter, unsubscribe anytime

MINDS Free Tools

AI background removal, brand stamping, and a LINE sticker maker — free design tools, right in your browser, no upload.

Use free

MINDS Group

Need actual printing or gifting services?

From premium printing to online ordering and festive gifts — the MINDS Group sister brands take it from here.

Ask on LINE