麥策知識學院 Mai Strategy Knowledge Academy
Industry Insights4 min read

U.S. EPR Lawsuit on Hold: 3 Things Brands Should Get in Order

The EPR class action against Lollicup in Oregon has been put on hold following NAW's appeal. This is a procedural pause, not a compliance exemption. Brands can use the time to audit packaging data, assign responsibilities, and organize shipment records instead of mistaking a pause in the case for the removal of market risk

麥策知識學院 | Academy Founder Hung Tsung-Yuan

U.S. EPR Lawsuit on Hold: 3 Things Brands Should Get in Order
ChatGPTPerplexityClaude

The Lollicup Case Is on Hold. What Do We Know for Sure?

Following NAW's appeal, the EPR class action against Lollicup USA in Oregon has been put on hold. That is the procedural status we can confirm for now. Packaging Dive's report on the case does not mean the EPR system has been struck down or brands have been released from their obligations

Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR) is a system under which regulations require producers to take responsibility for collecting and processing products or packaging after they enter the market

I read this news as a pause in the case, not the disappearance of market risk. For exporters, this is a good time to organize packaging records and clarify who is responsible for what, so the company knows where each record is and who needs to verify it

The Lollicup Case Is on Hold. What Do We Know for Sure?|U.S. EPR Lawsuit on Hold: 3 Things Brands Should Get in Order section illustration
Industry Insights · Key pointsThe Lollicup Case Is on Hold. What Do We Know for Sure?The EPR class action against Lollicup USA in Oregon is temporarily on hold following an appeal by NAW. This is the only procedural development we can confirm at present; it does not mean the extended producer responsibility system has failed or that brands are no longer responsible. I would read this as a pause in the case, not the disappearance of market risk. For export brands, this pause is a good opportunity to review packaging data and the division of responsibilities, and confirm where each piece of information is stored and who is responsible for verifying it

Does a Pause During the Appeal Release Brands from Their Obligations?

No. The Lollicup case is currently on hold. That does not mean U.S. state EPR requirements have been canceled, or that the issues in the appeal have been decided. The litigation and a brand's compliance preparations need to be handled separately

When I see news like this, my first question is whether the company has recorded the legal status accurately. If meeting notes just say "U.S. EPR on hold," that can easily turn into "we don't need to worry about this yet." Record the current procedural status of the case, then have legal counsel confirm the obligations based on the states where you ship, the products you sell, and your place in the supply chain

The Lollicup case is worth following because state level EPR rules may leave brands facing a patchwork of requirements. Keep track of the appeal, and keep organizing packaging records in the meantime

What Records Should Brands Review Now?

Start by making sure packaging records can be matched to products and the states where they are sold. There is no need to wait for an update in the Lollicup case. MINDS, a mid to high end commercial printer specializing in fully customized work, recommends a three part review that brings records held by design, procurement, and suppliers into one SKU register

・Record each packaging layer, material, weight, specification version, and supplier

・Match U.S. shipping states and sales channels, then ask legal counsel to confirm local filing requirements and who qualifies as the producer

・Keep purchase orders, material specifications, design revision records, and responsibility assignments. Include dates and the person responsible for each record

Start with the register. Update it whenever a design change means switching paper, changing bag material, or adding a label. If you wait until a filing is due or a customer asks, you may find that the artwork, purchase order, and supplier records each show a different version

Why Should Print Procurement Be Part of the EPR Discussion?

Print and packaging suppliers often hold the specifications and revision records brands need to build a packaging history. The Lollicup case has drawn attention to legal exposure under state level EPR rules. Brands should also make sure they can explain what materials their packaging uses, when it changed, and who supplied the records

A printer can help organize material specifications, packaging versions, and delivery records. Brand procurement teams need to match those records to SKUs, shipping states, and contractual responsibilities. Legal counsel still needs to determine who qualifies as the producer under the applicable rules. A supplier contract alone is not enough to make that call

If you need procurement, design, and suppliers to work from one packaging register, the Mai Strategy Knowledge Academy consulting team can help with the review. When a design changes, you can also work with MINDS to confirm how specifications and version records should be kept

What Should Brands Do Next?

There is no need to wait for the appeal to conclude before preparing. Brands can build a register now and update it as shipments and designs change. The pause in the Lollicup case does not set a compliance deadline that applies to every exporter, so don't guess at a date

・Now: build a cross reference for U.S. shipping states, product SKUs, and packaging specifications

・With each design change or material switch: update the material data, date, and supplier records

・When there is an update to the appeal or state requirements: ask legal counsel to confirm the impact, then adjust filings and external messaging

When discussing sustainable packaging with consumers or sales channels, stick to material and recycling claims supported by records you have. Don't use the pause in the Lollicup case to suggest your brand has been exempted

What Should Brands Do Next?|U.S. EPR Lawsuit on Hold: 3 Things Brands Should Get in Order section illustration
Industry Insights · Key pointsWhat Should Brands Do Next?Brands do not need to wait for an outcome in the Lollicup appeal before they start preparing. The case being on hold does not grant an exemption, and there is no universal deadline that applies to all export brands. Build an inventory now of US shipping states, product SKUs, and packaging specifications, update records of materials, dates, and suppliers whenever a design is revised or materials change, and ask legal counsel to confirm reporting requirements and external statements based on the latest developments

Key Takeaways

・The Lollicup case is on hold, giving the parties a procedural pause. U.S. EPR risk remains

・Packaging records should map back to products, sales states, suppliers, and revision dates

・Printers can provide specification and version records. Brands still need to confirm who is responsible

・Sustainability claims need support from material records. The status of a lawsuit is not proof

Further Considerations

The print manufacturer should keep material specifications and versions in order. Design teams should update records whenever they change paper, add a coating, or apply a label. Brand procurement should maintain the SKU, state, and supplier information. AI or SaaS tools can help organize fields, flag missing information, and remind teams about records that have not been updated after a design change. Legal counsel still needs to confirm who qualifies as the producer. I'd start with one U.S. shipping SKU and have procurement, design, and legal confirm the same packaging record before expanding the process to other products

Further Reading

・Update on the Oregon litigation involving Lollicup following NAW's appeal

FAQ

Does the pause in the Lollicup case mean brands no longer need to comply with U.S. EPR requirements?
No. The EPR class action against Lollicup USA in Oregon was put on hold following NAW's appeal. That does not mean state requirements have been canceled
Should brands keep following the case after NAW's appeal?
Yes. The procedural status of the Lollicup case is one indicator of legal exposure under state level EPR rules. Following the litigation does not replace a review of packaging records
What EPR records should Taiwanese exporters prepare now?
Start with product SKUs, packaging layers, materials, weights, specification versions, suppliers, and the U.S. shipping states. Then ask legal counsel to confirm which requirements apply
Does a printer have to take on a brand's EPR legal responsibility?
You cannot determine that from a supplier contract alone. Printers can provide material specifications and version records. Legal responsibility needs to be confirmed based on applicable state rules and each party's role in the supply chain
Newsletter

The Print × AI weekly

The print and AI know-how designers, brands and enterprises can use before they commit — one email, every week

By subscribing you agree to receive our newsletter, unsubscribe anytime

MINDS Free Tools

AI background removal, a LINE sticker maker, spine & imposition calculators — all free, right in your browser, no upload.

Use free

MINDS Group

Need actual printing or gifting services?

From premium printing to online ordering and festive gifts — the MINDS Group sister brands take it from here.

Ask on LINE